CHAPTER 14 - Room 107

Since Dotty, Rob’s daughter, had moved him to an Assisted Living facility, she no longer communicated with me in any way. (I only learned where he was from a friend of Rob’s who knew Dotty.) I visited him the next day.

There he was, living again in one room with one window overlooking a dull and never-changing view, plus a half-bath, and a TV. He still had no computer, no phone or working hearing aids. He was still living with strangers, under other peoples’ rules. He could walk around indoors, but always had to use an unnecessary walker. There were several dining areas, a lobby and a bright enclosed porch to use to break the monotony of a single room. There was also a “social” room, which Rob studiously avoided, calling it the “slumper” room, where people sat slumped in their chairs or wheelchairs, apparently asleep. He was not a big socializer, did not like bingo or sing-alongs.

JAILS WITH CURTAINS

At this place, I had to check in at the front desk at every visit. Since he had no phone, he never knew who might walk into his unlocked room or when. This building was cleaner and less shabby than the rehab facility had been. They offered an impressive list of services:

Independent Living    Assisted Living    Long Term Care    Hospice Care   Short Term Stays/Respite Free Home Visit   Month to Month Rental   No Income Verification   Aging in Place   Alzheimer’s and Dementia Care   Video Surveillance 24/7

In spite of all the supposedly available services, he had barely settled in when he succumbed to another undetected urinary tract infection and was hospitalized. He had always responded rapidly when treated with antibiotics at the onset of an infection. I was concerned that he was not getting proper care. I was also aware that manipulation of medications can be a very effective means of control. Did Dotty not provide the correct and complete information about Rob’s condition and current medications? Was this a poorly run facility? Perhaps. It proved, however to have more sinister, hidden dangers.

COLD COMFORT

Rob again endured hours of being alone, with only my visits most days, and the occasional but contentious episodes with Dotty and sometimes her husband. (I did not know if Rob’s granddaughters ever visited.) He missed his daily long walks in the park. He was always cold. The heater worked, but perhaps he needed steady warmth from caring people, from laughter and companionship. I often urged him to speak up, to protest, but he wouldn’t. He couldn’t.

Rob had always been a strong and often stubborn advocate of honesty and independence. He was not argumentative, pleading or whiney.  How chilling was it that he knew his daughter was deliberately torturing him, and he was helpless to resist?

IN HARM’S WAY

When Dotty placed him in Assisted Living, I realized that what she wanted was to harm him or worse, but not why. Was she in financial difficulty and needed his money, or in poor mental health, or addicted to drugs or alcohol? She put on a good front with her travels, her home on many acres, her lavish pool parties and fake concern for her father’s well-being. Some family caretakers suffer great stress because of time and money constraints, but Dotty was retired and was no doubt using Rob’s money.

I knew little about Rob’s past relationship with his daughter. He seemed to love and trust her, and she occasionally met him for lunch, phoned him, and included him in family dinners at holiday times. She was busy with her social events, travel, church, her children and grandchildren. Where and when she got her malice and intent to destroy him I do not know. I did not suspect it and I don’t think Rob did.

Were there some long-ago hurtful family issues that had been simmering in her mind?  I did not know the family history, and neighbors never mentioned anything. Only two things stand out in my memory. One time when Rob asked “Do you love your daughter?” I replied that I adored her. That was it. And on one birthday card early in our relationship he wrote “Til you came along, I was barely hanging on.”

THE TIPPING POINT

Was his initial hospitalization for an infection the time when Dotty hatched her plan to get rid of Rob and his problems? Had she been hating the job of helping him when all she wanted was to socialize, go on cruises and have fun? Also, incidentally, was she tired of waiting to get his money? After all, he was very old, but very strong, and had been overcoming many health issues for a long time. (I very likely made another mistake when, at an earlier birthday lunch for Rob, I remarked to Dotty that all of his siblings were still alive and longevity seemed to be a family trait.)

Then came the time when Dotty told Rob that he couldn’t drive any more. He could not understand, since he was not disabled, and had a perfect driving record. She told him that she  was giving his car - his beautifully maintained, nearly twenty-year-old treasure - to her granddaughter. Then, the ultimate shock – that his home must be sold. His beloved home, which he designed and loves and where he could live in peace.

NOWHERE TO GO

Rob was devastated. He would never go home. He was helpless. He could not stop her. He could not object. She is his only child and he must depend on her for any possible long - term help. The next three months were a spiral into hell for Rob, a horrible story of hate and greed, of despair and decline, with only a few bright spots from his friends and my family. He did not need to be in assisted living. For him, it was assisted dying.

HOW DO I COPE WITH MY FEELINGS WHEN SOMEONE I LOVE IS HURTING ME?

YOU CAN HELP YOURSELF AND OTHERS IF YOU KNOW

These are some of the most common though unexpressed thoughts of older people living with family violence: from CARIE.org:

“I FEEL SO ALONE”

“I FEEL LIKE THERE’S NOTING I CAN DO”

“I MUST HAVE BEEN A BAD PARENT”

“NO ONE WILL BELIEVE ME IF I TELL THEM”

“PEOPLE WILL THINK I DON’T LOVE MY FAMILY IF I GET HELP”

“IF I TRY TO GET HELP, IT COULD MAKE THINGS WORSE”

“WHO WILL HELP ME IF I PUT THEM OUT?”

elderly hands
June 26, 2025
Learn top signs of elder abuse by family members, so you or a loved one are prepared. Recognizing these signs early is crucial for prevention and protection.
This is Bob from the Murder by Family Story
May 6, 2025
What if you discovered that all the plans you had made for the last years of your life – even for your funeral-were going to be completely changed without your permission. (Keep reading even if you have no plans. Especially if you have no plans.)
Rob wearing a black jacket is standing in front of a white fence.
May 6, 2025
I discovered the shock of elder abuse by family the second hardest way. I also found out about the wrong kind of planning, or rather wrong planning and bad people. I watched, unaware, as a daughter and her family planned and carried out the murder of her father. It is an extreme example, but not rare. It happened because I did not know, and could not imagine, that a crime so hideous ever existed. The evil and horror is seared into my soul.
A rainbow is visible over a body of water.
May 6, 2025
There were some signs that my friend Rob might suffer abuse by his family. When we met, he had his life in very good order. He had a few common old-age problems – some arthritis, hearing, and memory loss – but none of it slowed him down much. He watched his diet, walked at least a mile each day and was never sick with even a cold. He mentioned that he had had several major surgeries in years past and that his daughter, Dotty, had helped him.
A woman is covering her face with her hands in front of a house.
May 6, 2025
When we met, Rob had his life in very good order. He had some common old-age problems - arthritis and some hearing loss - but none of it slowed him down much; he had a strong constitution. He watched his diet, walked at least a mile every day, and was seldom sick with even a cold. He mentioned that he had several major surgeries in past years and that Dotty, his daughter, had helped him after his wife died. He took one prescription medicine -for high cholesterol.
A black and white photo of a person standing on a beach at sunset.
May 6, 2025
After much trial and error in the treatment of Rob’s problems from long-ago radiation for prostate cancer, he underwent surgery for a permanent catheter. He handled it well, making the necessary adjustments to his routine. Over the next year, there were a few problems with urinary tract infections – UTIs - which were easily treated with antibiotics and hydration.
Rob and Jane posing for a picture in front of a lake.
May 6, 2025
Rob was recovering from surgery and getting his strength back, but had occasional urinary tract infections. His daughter, Dotty, was handling his medical appointments and his medications. His infections were treated with antibiotics and hydration, but often caused confusion and disorientation.
Rob in a wheelchair is walking down a hospital hallway.
May 6, 2025
After three days in the hospital recovering from a severe infection, Rob was taken to a rehab facility by his daughter, Dotty - against his wishes. Almost everyone, if given a choice between returning to their home or going to stay in a facility, would choose home, although some might really need to go there before returning home. Rob did not need to go to a live-in rehab facility. Rob was not given a choice. He was walking, dressing, caring for himself and clear-headed at the time of his discharge from the hospital.
A statue of a bird stands on a dock overlooking a body of water.
May 6, 2025
This was the start. I watched, helpless, as my friend Rob was forced into a rehab facility by his daughter, when he could have gone home from the hospital after recovering from an infection. Most people want to stay at home, if possible, when they need care. He especially loved his home because he had created it. His home was on the water, with wide open views of water and sky. He had transformed the original 2-story townhouse into a huge open space with vistas from both floors and striking décor.
Rob wearing a white hat is sitting in a chair.
May 6, 2025
As Rob spent a month in a rehab facility, it became clear to me that Rob’s daughter, Dotty, did not want to help him. She actually wanted to harm him, but in secret. I found that elder abuse by family was not an abstract abomination; it was a real-life horror story and I was a broken-hearted witness.
A silhouette of a father and daughter standing under a tree.
May 6, 2025
Rob was in a Rehab facility for a month. He did not need to be there and I could not understand why Dotty, his daughter, forced him to go. He did tell her that he wanted to be at home and could have managed well, but did not put up much of a fight when she ignored him.
A patio with a table and chairs surrounded by flowers.
May 6, 2025
Daughter isolates him in a rehab facility, seizes his home and car, and forces him into assisted living against his wishes.
A person 's hand is visible behind a foggy glass.
May 1, 2025
After spending a month in a rehab facility, Rob was in worse condition than when he entered. He did not need rehabilitation, so the confinement and isolation were a torment for him. His daughter, Dotty, was taking away his freedom to choose how he wanted to live his life. Now, she was transferring him to an assisted living facility.
Broken Heart Graphic
April 1, 2025
I hoped that when I executed my plan for exposing Rob’s daughter’s intentions to his neighborhood (where she grew up), that she would hear about it and deny my assertions. Thus she would incriminate herself. That was a foolish hope and it didn’t happen and probably caused her to be more careful – but no less deadly.