CHAPTER 15 - PROOF

Now Rob was trying to settle into another new life, in an Assisted Living institution. He was again very disoriented, restricted and isolated, except for a few days in a hospital for another untreated urinary tract infection. He did experience the same lack of everyday communication with others, poor attention to his medical needs, and lack of control of his life. And again, he did not need to be in an assisted living facility. 

I had to acknowledge the abuse he was undergoing, and decide if it was temporary or if it was deadly. In spite of all the signs, I could not face the fact that Dotty’s intention was to end not just the burden of his care, but to end his life.

PLUNDER AND PILLAGE

Earlier, when Dotty had requested that I give her a key to the house, I did so, but did not mention that I had a duplicate. I had debated whether or not to move his laptop, cameras, and any other valuables, to my house. I didn’t. One morning, after he had been in assisted living for about a week, I decided to check on these things.

When I entered, I saw that his house was torn apart. All the kitchen cabinets were open, and some were empty. The big television in the living room was on the floor. The large portable heater was unplugged. The dining room chairs were upended. Two smaller TVs and his laptop and cameras were gone. In the bedroom, every drawer, cabinet and closet was open and empty. There was a large pile of clothing on the bed. In his office, his books and papers were being pulled out onto the floor.

In shock, I left. I did not know what to do. I spoke with some of Rob’s neighbors. They had seen Dotty and her husband going in and out, but no one had any idea what to do. It seemed that his family were in a big hurry to get rid of all of his possessions. And of him. 

What could I do to stop them? At the first signs of abuse, after my failed plan to expose the abusers, I had decided not to try any government agencies, fearing the usual incompetence and slow response, and planned to contact his family doctor and an attorney. But this was all happening so fast.

ANOTHER SHOCK

I went back to Rob’s house the next morning to take some pictures of the ransacking. Unbelievably, everything was back in place! Was I losing my mind? Did they know I had been there? (Much later, after the house was sold, I guessed that the only reason for the “clean-up” was that someone was coming to look at the property - maybe a Realtor or prospective buyer.) 

I checked again the following morning – all torn up again! All of the kitchen cabinets were emptied into large plastic tubs. The three television sets were gone, along with this laptop and cameras, and the heater. His office was trashed.

Over the next few days, Dotty or her husband were there every day. It was obvious that they were planning for his death. They took his car, stripped his home and sold it while he was still alive. They cleared out his whole house – 86 years of memories, books, photos, tools, TVs, cameras, furniture, artwork, prized possessions – before he died. They dismantled and destroyed his whole life. It was as if he was being flayed alive: layer after layer of his strength, pride, dignity and hope were stripped. They killed his soul. Killing his body took a little longer.

SUDDENLY VULNERABLE

Rob was the perfect candidate to be a victim. Dotty was his only child. His siblings were not close. He did not have a circle of friends – just me and one couple who were longtime friends. They did as much as they could, by keeping in touch with Dotty, who they knew well, and visiting Rob when they could. They helped by giving me information, since Dotty no longer communicated with me. I had no legal status and Dotty no doubt was telling lies about me to everyone – and especially to Rob. A short-term illness and a deranged daughter led to his confinement, decline and death.

PREVENT THE TORMENT

Elder abuse by family is hard to detect and even harder to believe, especially if you do not even know that it exists. It is an epidemic with no real solution. Attempts to intervene and stop it are almost always a failure, due to the time and costs. Most victims of abuse by family are too old and sick to live through investigations, examinations and court proceedings. And, as horrifying as the actual abuse is, any attempts to stop it often lead to escalation of the abuse.

THE BEST DETERRENT IS TO PROTECT YOURSELF AND YOUR LOVED ONES

  • Learn about the risks and causes of elder abuse by family.
  • Educate older adults about the dangers and preventions.
  • Prepare legal and financial defenses – no joint bank accounts, proper power of attorney.
  • Encourage people to remain as socially active as possible.
  • Make a plan for your wishes if you become incapacitated.
  • If you have a designated health care agent, stay aware of their possibly changing situation, especially if it is a family member. (I don’t mean to imply that all family members are out to get you. Most are loving, caring people.)

BUT WHAT IF THEY AREN’T ?????

types of elder abuse to watch for - murder by family story
July 14, 2025
Elder abuse from family can come in many forms, whether emotional, physical, financial, or other types, know what to watch for and how to take action.
older person
June 26, 2025
Learn top signs of elder abuse by family members, so you or a loved one are prepared. Recognizing these signs early is crucial for prevention and protection.
This is Bob from the Murder by Family Story
May 6, 2025
What if you discovered that all the plans you had made for the last years of your life – even for your funeral – were going to be completely changed without your permission. (Keep reading even if you have no plans. Especially if you have no plans.)
Rob wearing a black jacket is standing in front of a white fence.
May 6, 2025
I discovered the shock of elder abuse by family the second hardest way. I also found out about the wrong kind of planning, or rather wrong planning and bad people. I watched, unaware, as a daughter and her family planned and carried out the murder of her father. It is an extreme example, but not rare. It happened because I did not know, and could not imagine, that a crime so hideous ever existed. The evil and horror is seared into my soul.
A rainbow is visible over a body of water.
May 6, 2025
There were some signs that my friend Rob might suffer abuse by his family. When we met, he had his life in very good order. He had a few common old-age problems – some arthritis, hearing, and memory loss – but none of it slowed him down much. He watched his diet, walked at least a mile each day and was never sick with even a cold. He mentioned that he had had several major surgeries in years past and that his daughter, Dotty, had helped him.
A woman is covering her face with her hands in front of a house.
May 6, 2025
When we met, Rob had his life in very good order. He had some common old-age problems - arthritis and some hearing loss - but none of it slowed him down much; he had a strong constitution. He watched his diet, walked at least a mile every day, and was seldom sick with even a cold. He mentioned that he had several major surgeries in past years and that Dotty, his daughter, had helped him after his wife died. He took one prescription medicine -for high cholesterol.
A black and white photo of a person standing on a beach at sunset.
May 6, 2025
After much trial and error in the treatment of Rob’s problems from long-ago radiation for prostate cancer, he underwent surgery for a permanent catheter. He handled it well, making the necessary adjustments to his routine. Over the next year, there were a few problems with urinary tract infections – UTIs - which were easily treated with antibiotics and hydration.
Rob and Jane posing for a picture in front of a lake.
May 6, 2025
Rob was recovering from surgery and getting his strength back, but had occasional urinary tract infections. His daughter, Dotty, was handling his medical appointments and his medications. His infections were treated with antibiotics and hydration, but often caused confusion and disorientation.
Rob in a wheelchair is walking down a hospital hallway.
May 6, 2025
After three days in the hospital recovering from a severe infection, Rob was taken to a rehab facility by his daughter, Dotty - against his wishes. Almost everyone, if given a choice between returning to their home or going to stay in a facility, would choose home, although some might really need to go there before returning home. Rob did not need to go to a live-in rehab facility. Rob was not given a choice. He was walking, dressing, caring for himself and clear-headed at the time of his discharge from the hospital.
A statue of a bird stands on a dock overlooking a body of water.
May 6, 2025
This was the start. I watched, helpless, as my friend Rob was forced into a rehab facility by his daughter, when he could have gone home from the hospital after recovering from an infection. Most people want to stay at home, if possible, when they need care. He especially loved his home because he had created it. His home was on the water, with wide open views of water and sky. He had transformed the original 2-story townhouse into a huge open space with vistas from both floors and striking décor.
Rob wearing a white hat is sitting in a chair.
May 6, 2025
As Rob spent a month in a rehab facility, it became clear to me that Rob’s daughter, Dotty, did not want to help him. She actually wanted to harm him, but in secret. I found that elder abuse by family was not an abstract abomination; it was a real-life horror story and I was a broken-hearted witness.
A silhouette of a father and daughter standing under a tree.
May 6, 2025
Rob was in a Rehab facility for a month. He did not need to be there and I could not understand why Dotty, his daughter, forced him to go. He did tell her that he wanted to be at home and could have managed well, but did not put up much of a fight when she ignored him.
A patio with a table and chairs surrounded by flowers.
May 6, 2025
Daughter isolates him in a rehab facility, seizes his home and car, and forces him into assisted living against his wishes.
A person 's hand is visible behind a foggy glass.
May 1, 2025
After spending a month in a rehab facility, Rob was in worse condition than when he entered. He did not need rehabilitation, so the confinement and isolation were a torment for him. His daughter, Dotty, was taking away his freedom to choose how he wanted to live his life. Now, she was transferring him to an assisted living facility.
Broken Heart Graphic
April 30, 2025
I hoped that when I executed my plan for exposing Rob’s daughter’s intentions to his neighborhood (where she grew up), that she would hear about it and deny my assertions. Thus she would incriminate herself. That was a foolish hope and it didn’t happen and probably caused her to be more careful – but no less deadly.
person in jail
April 29, 2025
Since Dotty, Rob’s daughter, had moved him to an Assisted Living facility, she no longer communicated with me in any way. (I only learned where he was from a friend of Rob’s who knew Dotty.) I visited him the next day.